Don’t Put Your Dreams in the Hands of Others

Imagine the following scenes throughout Shmueli’s life in the thriving religious community of Goshen, Indiana, and how he never fulfilled his dream to make aliyah and live in the Holy Land.

Scene 1.

Little Shmeuli is 7 years old and just finished examining a big picture book of Israel and it’s holy sites.

Shmueli:  Mommy, I want to move to Israel.  It looks really fun there!   Can we move mommy?

Mommy:  No, sorry sweetie.  Abba has a good job here in Goshen,  and anyway the Israeli kids are really too rough.  You might get hurt.  Maybe someday, but not now.

Scene 2.

Years later, Shmueli is now 16 and just finished viewing the Goshen Yeshiva senior class trip pictures of Israel on Facebook.

Shmueli:  Abba, looking at all those picture of Israel really makes we want to go there.  The Cohens made aliyah, why don’t we?

Abba:  It’s not a good idea to disrupt your yeshiva learning, Shmueli.  Learning in Israel is a lot different and it might be hard on you.  And anyway,  Mashiach will come some day soon and we will all go there!

Scene 3.

Shmueli is now 21 and in his third year of Goshen Yeshiva Beit Medrash.  After learning the halachot of Sheviit he feels the desire to move to Israel and consults with his Rebbi.

Shmueli:  Learning the halachot of sheviit has stirred up my feelings to make aliyah, and get land of my own so I can fulfill those mitzvot.  What do you think?

Rebbi:  Now is not a good time.  You’re still young, and anyway, your father has got college plans for you starting next year, right?  You have your whole life to make aliyah – don’t get all worked up about it now.  Think of your future.

Scene 4.

Shmueli is now 28 years old, married with four kids and a degree in programming.   After the Shabbat drasha about the meraglim, Shmueli approaches Rabbi Greenberg with a nagging question.

Shmueli:   Rabbi, I have been thinking about making aliyah lately.  The kids are still young, my wife is interested and I can support the family as a programmer.  I think it would work out fine!  What do you think?

Rabbi Greenberg:  Bad idea.  The government is filled with wicked people, Israeli children will be hard on your kids, your standard of living won’t be nearly the same.  Stay here.  You have a nice home, cars, a night seder – what more could you ask for?  Wait a few more years – until your kids are older.

Scene 5.

At age 35 Shmueli has a couple more kids and has advanced in his programming.  His oldest is 14 years old and is doing well in school.  After looking at another Nefesh B’Nefesh charter flight arrival on Arutz Sheva he calls the Rosh Yeshiva of Goshen Yeshiva to speak about making aliyah.

Shmueli:  …we would like to make aliyah.  We can support ourselves financially, my kids are doing well in school.  I would like to pursue the idea further.  What does the Rosh Yeshiva think?

Rosh Yeshiva:  Shmueli, I have know you a long time and have seen you grow to be quite a talmid chacham and a baal hesid.  But, you have to know that your son my not “find himself” in Israel.  You may find him doing “other things” – things that you don’t want to think about.  You have to think about your kids, and what is best for them.  Goshen is good for you and you are good for Goshen.  You have plenty of time to make aliyah.

Scene 6.

Ten years later, two kids are married and his other children are in school, some are doing poorly  and some are doing well.   After finding that an old friend on Facebook has moved to Israel, Shmueli turns to Yaakov, his chavruta of 13 years for his opinion.

Shmueli:  I just got an email from an old friend who made aliyah.  He says ‘It’s the best thing he has done and his family loves it there.’ !

Yaakov:  Man, I would put that on the back burner if I were you.   A lot of kids go off the derech.  It’s a big problem.  Maybe you should move when all your kids are grown and on their own.

Scene 7.

At age 61 Shmeuli is making plans for retirement with his friend and accountant, Hillel Ash.

Shmueli:  I think the time has come for me to retire and make aliyah, you are my accountant – what do you think?

Hillel:  You have a lot of people relying upon your support, both financial and personal.  You’ve got grandchildren who love to come visit you.   How can you leave all this behind?  Work for another eight to ten years and then go.  Stick around, your needed here in Goshen!

Scene 8.

Shmueli dies at age 79 leaving behind his wife, children, grandchildren and great grandchildren.  After the hespedim, Shmueli’s body and his closest family members board the next El Al flight to Israel for his burial place on Har HaZiytim.  As the plane taxis to the runway Shmueli’s wife converses with their oldest son.

Wife:  You know, your father always wanted to live in Israel….


Filed under Uncategorized

5 responses to “Don’t Put Your Dreams in the Hands of Others

  1. Neil Gillman

    Unfortunately this piece absolutely hits the mark time after time.

  2. Robert in Karnei

    Although its a well written piece and there is a lot of truth to it, Israel is not for everyone. It is rough and tough and….well I can go on for hours complaining, but the truth is I love it and wouldnt have it any other way., But, and a big but here, I can afford it. I worked for 25 years in Galut to be able to be taken advantage of here in Israel. Sure I could go on and make $200-$300 k a year and be left with $50k or so, but in the end its worth way more to me to enjoy life here, with my kids in the land that is ours. Arabs and terror, paleeze !! Its embarrasing how caught up we are in their problems and how, if we had any brains we’d swot them and all the other detractors away so they can go and feast on another pile of waste and leave us alone…but just as flies are a nuisance, so too are lousy neighbors, government bureacracy, other Israelis, etc. None of it are going to stop me from living the dream. But its not for everyone and each person should be given the respect of deciding if it is for them. If they chose not to, kol hakavod and enjoy life. If they chose to make aliya, be prepared for the ride of your life – for good and for bad – but know that you did it your way and are part of the most magical, interesting story of all humankind !!

  3. Ariela

    love this piece, it hits home we are doing Aliyah and are excited.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s